Answer: B. Neanderthals were a separate, parallel lineage that eventually went extinct. Larger cranial capacity does not establish direct ancestry. NCERT Class 12 Biology Chapter 6, pages 124–125, treats Neanderthals as a distinct species in the hominid tree, not as a precursor to modern humans.
Why A is wrong: A is wrong because Neanderthals actually did have a slightly larger cranial capacity (~1400 cc) compared to modern Homo sapiens (~1300–1400 cc). This option contradicts the established fact.
Why C is wrong: C is wrong because while the relationship between brain size and intelligence is complex, the claim is too absolute — brain size does correlate with cognitive capacity across species to some degree. The real refutation is lineage, not brain-size irrelevance.
Why D is wrong: D is wrong because Neanderthals and Homo sapiens did coexist for a period — there is evidence of temporal and geographic overlap. This factual error would weaken, not support, the refutation.