First Element Anomaly

8 MCQs9-step worked example
Source: NCERT p-Block ElementsPYQ coverage: NEET 2026Official key: NTA-verifiedLast updated: 27 Sep 2026

First Element Anomaly, explained for NEET

The anomaly sits at the first member of each p-block group — B, C, N, O, F — not at the heaviest congener. This is the reversal students get wrong most often: they have trained on inert-pair questions where the deviant element is at the bottom, and they carry that habit into a question that is asking about the top.

Three causes operate together, and NEET options routinely offer only one of them:

  1. Small atomic size — the highest charge/radius ratio in the group.
  2. High electronegativity — F and O are the two most electronegative elements.
  3. Absence of d orbitals in the valence shell — the second-period elements have only 2s and 2p available.

An option that explains the anomaly by electronegativity alone is incomplete, and NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172, gives these causes for nitrogen and adds a fourth, high ionisation enthalpy. Quote them all when a question asks "why."

The third cause does the heavy lifting in questions that look like oxidation-state problems. Fluorine shows only −1, while Cl, Br and I show +1, +3, +5 and +7, because those heavier halogens can expand their octet into empty 3d, 4d or 5d orbitals; fluorine has no such orbital. The same logic explains why NF₃ has no expanded-octet analogue while PF₅ and PCl₅ exist comfortably.

The second-period elements also form pπ–pπ multiple bonds — N≡N, O=O, C=C — because their small 2p orbitals overlap sideways effectively. Phosphorus and sulphur do not; they catenate into single-bonded chains and rings instead (P₄, S₈). Expecting nitrogen to build P₄-style catenated structures is a direct consequence of forgetting which row you are in.

Watch-out: when a stem says "differs from the rest of its group," read the option list for position first. If an option names the second member, or the heaviest member, it is answering a different question.

Can you answer these First Element Anomaly MCQs?

Select an option to see the explanation. Wrong answers show why your choice was tempting — and name the exact trap it exploits.

MCQ 1Easy RecallPractice

In each group of the p-block, the member whose properties depart most sharply from the rest of the group is:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: A. A is correct. It is the first member that departs from the group, being much smaller and more electronegative than its congeners and having no d orbitals in its valence shell. NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172 sets out the case of nitrogen, whose covalence is limited to four for exactly that reason; boron behaves the same way in Group 13.

Why B is wrong: B is wrong because the second member (Al, Si, P, S, Cl) is the group standard against which the first member's anomaly is measured, not the anomaly itself.

Why C is wrong: C is wrong because it applies the inert-pair pattern (a separate, bottom-of-group phenomenon) to a question about the first-element anomaly.

Why D is wrong: D is wrong because it confuses this anomaly with oxidation-state deviations at the heaviest congener, which have a different cause entirely.

MCQ 2Easy RecallPractice

The absence of d orbitals in the valence shell of second-period elements is a consequence of:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: C. C is correct. The n = 2 shell has only 2s and 2p subshells; d subshells first become available at n = 3. NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172, lists this as a distinct cause from size and electronegativity.

Why A is wrong: A is wrong because electronegativity is a separate contributing cause of the anomaly; it does not determine which subshells exist in a given principal shell.

Why B is wrong: B is wrong because small size is likewise a separate cause. Atomic radius and orbital availability are independent facts about the second period.

Why D is wrong: D is wrong because the inert-pair effect concerns reluctance of ns² electrons to bond in heavy 5p and 6p elements — an unrelated, bottom-of-group phenomenon.

MCQ 3Easy RecallPractice

The anomalous behaviour of the first member of each p-block group is attributed mainly to:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: B. B is correct. The first member is far smaller and more electronegative than the rest of its group, and its n = 2 valence shell carries no d orbitals, so it cannot expand its octet. The consequence NCERT records for nitrogen on page 172 of Class 12 Chemistry, Chapter 7 (pre-rationalisation edition) — covalence capped at four, no pentahalide — follows from the last of these.

Why A is wrong: A is wrong on two counts: second-period elements have HIGH ionisation enthalpy, and the anomaly comes from the ABSENCE of d orbitals, not their presence.

Why C is wrong: C is wrong because metallic character and the inert-pair effect are properties of heavy congeners at the bottom of a group, not of the first element.

Why D is wrong: D is wrong because it inverts every term: the first element is small and highly electronegative, and has no valence-shell d orbitals.

MCQ 4Direct ApplicationPractice

Fluorine exhibits only the −1 oxidation state, while chlorine, bromine and iodine also show +1, +3, +5 and +7. The cause is that fluorine:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: B. B is correct. Positive oxidation states for halogens require octet expansion into empty d orbitals; fluorine's valence shell (n = 2) has none, so it is restricted to −1. This is the multi-step use of the third anomaly cause described in NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172.

Why A is wrong: A is wrong because small size contributes to the general anomaly but does not by itself prohibit positive oxidation states. Orbital availability is the operative cause here.

Why C is wrong: C is wrong because H–F is in fact the strongest hydrogen halide bond, and bond strength does not govern which oxidation states an element can access.

Why D is wrong: D is wrong because fluorine's electronegativity ranking explains why it is never positively oxidised by another element, but the reason it cannot reach +5 or +7 is the missing d subshell.

MCQ 5Direct ApplicationPractice

NF₃ exists but no nitrogen analogue of PF₅ is known. The reason is that nitrogen:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: D. D is correct. Phosphorus can promote an electron into its empty 3d orbitals to form five bonds; nitrogen's n = 2 valence shell offers only four orbitals (one s and three p), so its maximum covalency is 4 (as in NH₄⁺) and five bonds are impossible. NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172.

Why A is wrong: A is wrong because nitrogen is MORE electronegative than phosphorus, and in any case electronegativity does not set a covalency ceiling.

Why B is wrong: B is wrong because it restates the observation rather than explaining it — and nitrogen does form multiple bonds (N≡N), just not a fifth bond to fluorine.

Why C is wrong: C is wrong because half-filled-subshell stability affects ionisation enthalpy, not the maximum covalency. Nitrogen bonds readily to three fluorines despite the half-filled 2p.

MCQ 6Direct ApplicationPractice

Nitrogen exists as N≡N while phosphorus exists as P₄, and oxygen as O=O while sulphur as S₈. The structural difference arises because second-period elements:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: C. C is correct. Compact 2p orbitals give strong sideways overlap, so N and O satisfy their valency through pπ–pπ multiple bonding. The diffuse 3p orbitals of P and S overlap poorly sideways, so those elements catenate into single-bonded P₄ and S₈ instead.

Why A is wrong: A is wrong because ionisation enthalpy governs electron loss, not the choice between multiple bonding and catenation. Carbon has a high ionisation enthalpy and catenates extensively.

Why B is wrong: B is wrong because second-period elements have NO valence-shell d orbitals — that absence is a defining feature of the anomaly.

Why D is wrong: D is wrong because N and O are MORE electronegative than P and S, and electronegativity does not determine pπ–pπ overlap efficiency anyway.

MCQ 7Concept TrapPractice

A student explains the first-element anomaly using high electronegativity alone. The explanation is incomplete because it omits:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: A. A is correct. Electronegativity is only part of it. Small size concentrates the charge, and the absence of valence-shell d orbitals is what caps the covalence — the point NCERT makes for nitrogen on page 172 of Class 12 Chemistry, Chapter 7 (pre-rationalisation edition). An answer resting on electronegativity alone cannot explain why NF5 does not exist.

Why B is wrong: B is wrong because metallic character and larger radii describe the heavier members of a group, the opposite end from where this anomaly sits.

Why C is wrong: C is wrong because the inert-pair effect operates on heavy 5p and 6p congeners at the bottom of a group — it has no bearing on the first element.

Why D is wrong: D is wrong because half-filled-subshell stability explains local ionisation-enthalpy reversals within a period, not the group-wide first-element anomaly.

MCQ 8Concept TrapPractice

A question asks which element "differs markedly from the remaining members of its group." An option naming the heaviest congener is offered. The correct reading is that:

Show answer and why every option is right or wrong

Answer: D. D is correct. The first-element anomaly (small size, high electronegativity, no d orbitals) and heavy-congener oxidation-state deviations are distinct phenomena with distinct causes. A stem about the first-element anomaly is answered by the first member. NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172.

Why A is wrong: A is wrong because it generalises the bottom-of-group pattern into a rule that overrides the stem. Metallic character peaking at the bottom is true but answers a different question.

Why B is wrong: B is wrong because the second member defines the group standard; it is what the first member is compared against.

Why C is wrong: C is wrong because the two deviations have different causes and different diagnostic questions. Treating them as interchangeable guarantees a wrong selection when the stem specifies one.

Free NEET study resources

Get a structured 30-day study plan and a complete formula booklet — delivered to your inbox instantly.

How do you solve a First Element Anomaly question? A worked example

  1. 1

    Given

    Fluorine (Z = 9, exact — atomic numbers are counting integers) and chlorine (Z = 17, exact). Observed oxidation states: F shows only −1; Cl shows −1, +1, +3, +5, +7.

  2. 2

    Required

    Explain, from electronic structure, why fluorine is restricted to −1 while chlorine accesses positive states up to +7.

  3. 3

    Concept

    First-element anomaly, third cause: second-period elements have no d subshell in the valence shell. Positive oxidation states in halogens require the octet to expand beyond eight electrons, which demands empty d orbitals at the same principal quantum number. NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, page 172.

  4. 4

    Formula

    No numerical formula applies. The governing structural relation is: maximum covalency is limited by the number of orbitals available in the valence shell.

  5. 5

    Substitution

    F: [He] 2s² 2p⁵ — valence shell n = 2, subshells available: 2s, 2p only.
    Cl: [Ne] 3s² 3p⁵ — valence shell n = 3, subshells available: 3s, 3p, 3d (empty).

  6. 6

    Calculation

    Fluorine's valence shell holds 4 orbitals (one 2s, three 2p) = 8 electron capacity. With 7 valence electrons, F can gain 1 to reach 8, giving −1. It cannot unpair and promote electrons because there is no higher-energy orbital in n = 2 to receive them. Maximum covalency = 1.

    Chlorine's valence shell holds 4 orbitals plus five empty 3d orbitals. Promoting 3p and 3s electrons into 3d unpairs them stepwise: one promotion gives 3 unpaired electrons (+3), two give 5 (+5), three give 7 (+7).

    The atomic numbers and orbital counts used here are exact counting integers and do not enter any significant-figure accounting.

  7. 7

    Final answer

    Fluorine is confined to −1 because its n = 2 valence shell has no d orbitals to accept promoted electrons, so its octet cannot expand. Chlorine's empty 3d orbitals permit stepwise promotion, yielding +1, +3, +5 and +7 in addition to −1.

  8. 8

    Common trap

    Attributing fluorine's single oxidation state to its electronegativity. Electronegativity explains why fluorine is never oxidised by another element — nothing pulls electrons harder — but the structural reason it cannot reach +5 or +7 even in principle is orbital unavailability. A stem asking "why can F not show +5?" is testing the d-orbital cause, and an electronegativity option is the distractor.

  9. 9

    Similar NEET-style question

    Oxygen shows a maximum covalency of 2 while sulphur reaches 6 in SF₆. Identify the electronic-structure reason and state whether it is the same cause that restricts fluorine to −1.
    *(Answer: yes — the same cause. O has no valence-shell d orbital at n = 2; S has empty 3d orbitals allowing expansion to six bonds.)*

What to remember before solving First Element Anomaly questions

In the NEET syllabus; removed from current NCERT.

Certain important trends can be observed in the chemical behaviour of group 13 elements. The tri-chlorides, bromides and iodides of all these elements being covalent in nature are hydrolysed in water. Species like tetrahedral [M(OH)4]– and octahedral [M(H2O)6]3+, except in boron, exist in aqueous medium. The monomeric trihalides, being electron deficient, are strong Lewis acids. Boron trifluoride easily reacts with Lewis bases such as NH3 to complete octet around boron. F3B + :NH3 → F3B←NH3 It is due to the absence of d orbitals that the maximum covalence of B is 4. Since the d orbitals are available with Al and other elements, the maximum covalence can be expected beyond 4. Most of the other metal halides (e.g., AlCl3) are dimerised through halogen bridging (e.g., Al2Cl6). The metal species completes its octet by accepting electrons from halogen in these halogen bridged molecules. Problem 11.3 Boron is unable to form BF6 3– ion. Explain. Solution Due to non-availability of d orbitals, boron is unable to expand its octet. Therefore, the maximum covalence of boron cannot exceed 4.

-- NCERT Class 11 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 11, p. 320

In the NEET syllabus; removed from current NCERT.

Like first member of other groups, carbon also differs from rest of the members of its group. It is due to its smaller size, higher electronegativity, higher ionisation enthalpy and unavailability of d orbitals. In carbon, only s and p orbitals are available for bonding and, therefore, it can accommodate only four pairs of electrons around it. This would limit the maximum covalence to four whereas other members can expand their covalence due to the presence of d orbitals. Carbon also has unique ability to form pπ– pπ multiple bonds with itself and with other atoms of small size and high electronegativity. Few examples of multiple bonding are: C=C, C ≡ C, C = O, C = S, and C ≡ N. Heavier elements do not form pπ– pπ bonds because their atomic orbitals are too large and diffuse to have effective overlapping. Carbon atoms have the tendency to link with one another through covalent bonds to form chains and rings. This property is called catenation. This is because C—C bonds are very strong. Down the group the size increases and electronegativity decreases, and, thereby, tendency to show catenation decreases. This can be clearly seen from bond enthalpies values. The order of catenation is C > > Si > Ge ≈ Sn. Lead does not show catenation. Bond enthalpy / kJ mol–1: C—C 348, Si—Si 297, Ge—Ge 260, Sn—Sn 240

-- NCERT Class 11 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 11, p. 325

In the NEET syllabus; removed from current NCERT.

However, it does not form compounds in +5 oxidation state with halogens as nitrogen does not have d-orbitals to accommodate electrons from other elements to form bonds. Nitrogen is restricted to a maximum covalency of 4 since only four (one s and three p) orbitals are available for bonding. The heavier elements have vacant d orbitals in the outermost shell which can be used for bonding (covalency) and hence, expand their covalence as in PF6–. Anomalous properties of nitrogen Nitrogen differs from the rest of the members of this group due to its small size, high electronegativity, high ionisation enthalpy and non-availability of d orbitals. Nitrogen has unique ability to form pπ-pπ multiple bonds with itself and with other elements having small size and high electronegativity (e.g., C, O). Heavier elements of this group do not form pπ-pπ bonds as their atomic orbitals are so large and diffuse that they cannot have effective overlapping. Thus, nitrogen exists as a diatomic molecule with a triple bond (one s and two p) between the two atoms. Consequently, its bond enthalpy (941.4 kJ mol–1) is very high. On the contrary, phosphorus, arsenic and antimony form single bonds as P–P, As–As and Sb–Sb while bismuth forms metallic bonds in elemental state. However, the single N–N bond is weaker than the single P–P bond because of high interelectronic repulsion of the non-bonding electrons, owing to the small bond length. As a result the catenation tendency is weaker in nitrogen. Another factor which affects the chemistry of nitrogen is the absence of d orbitals in its valence shell. Besides restricting its covalency to four, nitrogen cannot form dπ –pπ bond as the heavier elements can e.g., R3P = O or R3P = CH2 (R = alkyl group).

-- NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, p. 172

In the NEET syllabus; removed from current NCERT.

Ionisation enthalpy decreases down the group. It is due to increase in size. However, the elements of this group have lower ionisation enthalpy values compared to those of Group15 in the corresponding periods. This is due to the fact that Group 15 elements have extra stable half-filled p orbitals electronic configurations. Because of the compact nature of oxygen atom, it has less negative electron gain enthalpy than sulphur. However, from sulphur onwards the value again becomes less negative upto polonium. Next to fluorine, oxygen has the highest electronegativity value amongst the elements. Within the group, electronegativity decreases with an increase in atomic number. This implies that the metallic character increases from oxygen to polonium. Oxidation states and trends in chemical reactivity The elements of Group 16 exhibit a number of oxidation states (Table 7.6). The stability of -2 oxidation state decreases down the group. Polonium hardly shows –2 oxidation state. Since electronegativity of oxygen is very high, it shows only negative oxidation state as –2 except in the case of OF2 where its oxidation state is + 2. Other elements of the group exhibit + 2, + 4, + 6 oxidation states but + 4 and + 6 are more common. Anomalous behaviour of oxygen The anomalous behaviour of oxygen, like other members of p-block present in second period is due to its small size and high electronegativity. One typical example of effects of small size and high electronegativity is the presence of strong hydrogen bonding in H2O which is not found in H2S.

-- NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, p. 187

In the NEET syllabus; removed from current NCERT.

The absence of d orbitals in oxygen limits its covalency to four and in practice, rarely exceeds two. On the other hand, in case of other elements of the group, the valence shells can be expanded and covalence exceeds four. (i) Reactivity with hydrogen: All the elements of Group 16 form hydrides of the type H2E (E = O, S, Se, Te, Po). Some properties of hydrides are given in Table 7.7. Their acidic character increases from H2O to H2Te. The increase in acidic character can be explained in terms of decrease in bond enthalpy for the dissociation of H–E bond down the group. Owing to the decrease in enthalpy for the dissociation of H–E bond down the group, the thermal stability of hydrides also decreases from H2O to H2Po. All the hydrides except water possess reducing property and this character increases from H2S to H2Te. Table 7.7: Properties of Hydrides of Group 16 Elements (H2O, H2S, H2Se, H2Te) — m.p/K: 273, 188, 208, 222; b.p/K: 373, 213, 232, 269; H–E distance/pm: 96, 134, 146, 169; HEH angle (°): 104, 92, 91, 90; ΔfH/kJ mol–1: –286, –20, 73, 100; ΔdissH (H–E)/kJ mol–1: 463, 347, 276, 238; Dissociation constant (aqueous solution, 298 K): 1.8×10–16, 1.3×10–7, 1.3×10–4, 2.3×10–3.

-- NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, p. 188

In the NEET syllabus; removed from current NCERT.

The fluorine atom has no d orbitals in its valence shell and therefore cannot expand its octet. Being the most electronegative, it exhibits only –1 oxidation state. Anomalous behaviour of fluorine Like other elements of p-block present in second period of the periodic table, fluorine is anomalous in many properties. For example, ionisation enthalpy, electronegativity, and electrode potentials are all higher for fluorine than expected from the trends set by other halogens. Also, ionic and covalent radii, m.p. and b.p., enthalpy of bond dissociation and electron gain enthalpy are quite lower than expected. The anomalous behaviour of fluorine is due to its small size, highest electronegativity, low F-F bond dissociation enthalpy, and non availability of d orbitals in valence shell. Most of the reactions of fluorine are exothermic (due to the small and strong bond formed by it with other elements). It forms only one oxoacid while other halogens form a number of oxoacids. Hydrogen fluoride is a liquid (b.p. 293 K) due to strong hydrogen bonding.

-- NCERT Class 12 Chemistry (pre-2023 edition), Chapter 7, p. 200

More in p-Block Elements: 12 exam traps and mistakes from its other lessons.

First Element Anomaly questions from past NEET papers

1 question from NEET 2026. Answers verified against NTA official keys.

All 18 past-paper questions from p-Block Elements →

Sources

Page numbers are the ones printed in the current NCERT textbook (2023 rationalised edition), unless marked pre-2023. The books are free at ncert.nic.in.

Report an error · Every fix is public: corrections log

Test yourself on this topic with real past-paper questions:

Practice this topic →